| Author | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Fadin03 |
|||
|
Didn't really like the live version from either on tues then I kinda liked it when Kris sang it again wed but now I find myself replaying the studio over
and over
|
|||
kw2004 |
|||
|
My gosh, the studio verion is SO SO SO much better! Like a million times better. Not a bad written song, just not a good live song IMO.
|
|||
dabri99 |
|||
|
After you listen to it over and over it's pretty good. It's like a lot of songs it grows on you.
|
|||
NJKellyFan |
|||
|
I heard Adam's version earlier today on Sirius-XM radio. I stand by my undecided vote lol.
|
|||
Un4gitible |
|||
|
I agree with my local radio station - worst coronation song in the history of idol. They have sworn not to play it and I hope they stick by that haha
|
|||
feisty4ever |
|||
|
^^^^i agree w/ your local station, un4gitible! this is what they gave up the songwriter competition for!?!?! i cant believe that those three experienced
writers couldnt come up w/ better than that. what a farce...IMO, kara knew she had it in the bag and didnt care about quality. grrrrr.
if any of you who dont like the song care to let AI know that (you can e-mail idol.web@fox.com), all of us songwriters standing on the outside looking in would greatly appreciate it...maybe they will bring the writer's competition back next year. thx for your feedback on the poll, y'all...and for tolerating my little b*tch session here |
|||
KellysMomCalledMeFine |
|||
|
Ridiculous
Posts: 4796 (05/26/09 9:03 AM) |
KellysMomCalledMeFine wrote:I would like to change my "it's okay" vote to "I love it!" It's really grown on me, and Kris did an EXCELLENT job with it. To me, this song is the 2nd best coronation song, behind AMLT. 1. AMLT 2. No Boundaries 3. I Believe 4. Time of My Life 5. This Is My Now 6. Inside Your Heaven 7. Flying Without Wings (it wasn't an original!) 8. Do I Make You Proud (meh!) |
||
Houster |
|||
|
|
|||
cc |
|||
|
^ That was great.
And that girl is good. I think she'll be good
in theater (if she isn't already). Thanks for posting, Houster.
|
|||
jpsketch |
|||
|
I actually like the song. I mean, 'A Moment Like This' and 'I Believe' are really the ONLY good coronation songs. Every other one has been pure
trash, but maybe because I love Adam so much that I can enjoy listening to his version.
Kris' kinda sucks though. . . |
|||