NJKellyFan wrote:I hope it stays the girls goodbye song!
Eeek, Already Gone was the girl's "goodbye" song!!![]()
do they usually keep the same song for the girls and guys all season?
| Author | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
JosephKin18 |
|||
NJKellyFan wrote:I hope it stays the girls goodbye song! do they usually keep the same song for the girls and guys all season? |
|||
Crystal |
|||
|
I guessed the bottom 3 correctly. I don't think there were any surprises there. What did surprise me was the girl that went home. I thought the first girl
they told was safe did a terrible job at her solo.
|
|||
JosephKin18 |
|||
|
Was that Karla? yeah her solo was mehhhhhhhh
|
|||
starbaby0103 |
|||
|
i was a little disappointed that "already gone" was the goodbye song....just b/c i really wanted to see a choreographer's interpretation. my bff & i were convinced they would use it for a dance this season! although i guess this is prob better exposure for it. the wrong guy went home...imo, they should have sent vittolio home to work on his technique instead of letting him into the top 20 to begin with. i think he's really talented but really raw. in another 2 years, after serious study....he would be amazing! i agreed that paris was the weakest of the 3 girls. but none of the solos were particularly inspiring. |
|||
livelatino80 |
|||
|
maybe kelly will perform it on the show some time. good promo
|
|||
PsyMomPA |
|||
|
Darn storms cut out the last 30 minutes, so who went home?
|
|||
JosephKin18 |
|||
PsyMomPA wrote:Paris and Tony |
|||
cc |
|||
|
I also guessed the bottom three, but thought Jonathan and Karla would go home.
I thought as overall dancers, Paris was better than Karla, who I thought seems a little stiff. I think one of the things that saved her was that vertical split that she does -- which Melody (season one) used to do, but in the end, they couldn't get away from the fact that that was pretty much the only thing she does best, and I think might be the same with Karla. I think they sent Paris home, because like Nigel said, compared to the other female contemporary dancers, she's just not that strong. Same with Tony's case. I thought Jonathan was more raw and needs more practice. But I think Tony got compared with Phillip, who's a much better pop-locker (?). Also, it seems that from the audition rounds, he's been barely making it, and so apparently hasn't quite gotten there. So, how does it work again... You can't go back if you've made it to the top 20? Too bad, if I remembered it correctly. That's why I keep on thinking, if you're not that good yet, better for you to be cut in the auditions round, so you'll have a chance to come back better the next year. |
|||
PsyMomPA |
|||
|
Thanks.
|
|||
cc |
|||
|
I heard on the radio this morning that Mrs. Tom Cruise is performing on... Thursday?
I wish this is on Tuesdays and Weds, instead. Weds. too long for me to wait.
|
|||
Crystal |
|||
cc wrote:I knew that Katie Holmes was at some point, but I didn't know that Tom Cruise was as well...interesting. |
|||
woohoo02 |
|||
|
I keep forgetting that this is on! I missed last week and now I missed tonight. Darn it! Is there a place online to watch full episodes?
|
|||
KellysMomCalledMeFine |
|||
|
Ridiculous
Posts: 4833 (06/16/09 11:19 PM) |
^ I thought it was on Wednesday and Thursdays, not Tuesdays?
|
||
JosephKin18 |
|||
|
^Yep you're right!
|
|||
NJKellyFan |
|||
woohoo02 wrote:Lisa - You do the same thing my husband does With Idol
being on Tues and Weds, he keeps forgetting that "dance" is on Weds and Thurs haha. So you haven't missed it yet, it's on tonight |
|||
cc |
|||
Crystal wrote: Crystal... Sorry if my post created confusion, but I did mean Katie Holmes. For some reason, when I was typing, I went blank and can't think of Katie's name so I said Mrs. Tom Cruise. And then had to leave the board,
didn't have time to go back and edit by the time I remembered her name.
|
|||
woohoo02 |
|||
|
Ooooooh! LOL Wednesday and Thursday! HAHAHA. I still missed last weeks' though. But YAY that I can catch it tonight!
|
|||
Crystal |
|||
cc wrote:haha, well, apparently I can't read and just skipped over the Mrs. Whoops. Tonight did not feel as good overall as the first week. My favorite dancers are definitely Kayla and Ashley. My favorite couple is Phillip and Jeanine. Anyone else have favorites yet? |
|||
KellysMomCalledMeFine |
|||
|
Ridiculous
Posts: 4839 (06/17/09 10:04 PM) |
I love Jonathan, Jason, and Phillip for the guys. Jeanine and Kayla for the girls.
Jonathan and his partner were my favorite of the night. I can't stand Ade (the pick in his hair REALLY bothers me), but he's actually really good. |
||
NJKellyFan |
|||
|
We were having dinner with another couple, so I missed all but the very last routine. But based on the recap, I'm with Crystal...it didn't seem all
that impressive this week. Maybe I'll change my mind when I watch it back on the DVR.
|
|||