Quote:
in "Addicted" Kelly does in fact go down to an Eb3, listen when she says "You've taken over me" right before the bridge, that's when she sings the Eb3,


sorry, we both earn a living the same way, and i'm extremely passionate and protective about the technical aspects of her vocals and music to a degree that would likely frighten people. according to 440.00 tuning, the e-flat you have cited (assuming you're referring to the backup alto line, as the melody contains no e-flat):

..f[x]........f#.......b-flat.....b-flat........c.......d-flat......c
(you've.....ta...-...ken........o........-....ver.....me....-....e)
......................................f#............f........e-flat
.....................................(o.......-.....ver....me)

is an e-flat4.