Yuku free message boards
Username or E-mail:
Password:
Forgot
Password?
Sign Up
Grab the Yuku app
Search:
Home
Discussions
Kelly Clarkson
The Band
Appearances
Hall of Fame
Piper's Corner
Requests & Polls
Sales & Airplay Charts
Off Topic
Off Topic
American Idol
In Loving Memory
Tours
Piece By Piece
Honda Civic Tour w/ Maroon 5
Summer 2012 w/ The Fray
Stronger
All I Ever Wanted
Summer 2009
2 Worlds 2 Voices
My December
Addicted
Hazel Eyes
Breakaway
Media
Press
Video
Creative Corner
Pictures
KCE Links
Calendar
Photos
KC Links
Twitter
Instagram
Facebook
Official Site
Youtube
Vevo
German Fanclub
WhoSay
RSS
Email
Kelly Clarkson Express
>
American Idol
>
AMERICAN IDOL SEASON 8 "Hollywood Week" - will make new thread when Top 36 starts **SPOILERS INSIDE**
0 Points
Search this Topic:
Remove this ad
«Prev
1
2
3
4
5
…
19
20
Next»
Jump
Reply
New Topic
New Poll
Forum Jump
Announcements
Kelly Clarkson
The Band
Appearances
Hall of Fame
Piper's Corner
Request/Poll/Favorites Forum
Sales and Airplay Charts
Piece By Piece Tour
Honda Civic Tour with Maroon 5
Summer 2012 with The Fray
Stronger Tour
All I Ever Wanted Tour
Summer Shows 2009
2 Worlds - 2 Voices Tour
My December Tour
Addicted Tour
Hazel Eyes Tour
Breakaway Tour
2002
Press
KCE Media
2004
Creative Corner
2008
Pictures
2010
2005
2006
2009
2007
2003
2011
Off Topic
American Idol
In Loving Memory
Re: AMERICAN IDOL SEASON 8 "Hollywood Week" - will make new thread when Top 36 starts **SPOILERS INSIDE**
Author
Comment
cc
#1
[-]
Hot Damn!
Posts
: 10161
01/28/09 9:02 AM
Relating to the guy with the guitar... If the judges think a contestant is good, but they have some concerns about him... Then why not just let this person through and let the natural process take care of it? If the contestant isn't really not good, then I think he/she would be weeded out sooner or later. But at least give him a chance.
I really think their judging is a lot whimsical. I know they look for the "it" factor. But in some reality shows, like ANTM, I think what they usually look for is a drive, and love for the profession, and this guy with the guitar seems to really love music. Having said this, I think he needs some growing up to do, but I don't think it's up for the judges to eliminate him at this stage for that reason. You never know... He might grow up quickly during the competition. But as it was, they took that opportunity away from him.
Instead, they put through a lot of contestant who are obviously just for entertainment value, or may have some average talent, but are not real musicians, etc. Although, in the end, I know it doesn't really matter because the real good ones should've advanced. It just really annoys me how subjective the judging is. But what do I really expect, right? lol.
Also, I didn't like the editing. They kept flashing between the audition room to the family, that you never really heard the judges real reason for not putting him through.
More
My Recent Posts
Reply
Quote
Reply
Forum Jump
Announcements
Kelly Clarkson
The Band
Appearances
Hall of Fame
Piper's Corner
Request/Poll/Favorites Forum
Sales and Airplay Charts
Piece By Piece Tour
Honda Civic Tour with Maroon 5
Summer 2012 with The Fray
Stronger Tour
All I Ever Wanted Tour
Summer Shows 2009
2 Worlds - 2 Voices Tour
My December Tour
Addicted Tour
Hazel Eyes Tour
Breakaway Tour
2002
Press
KCE Media
2004
Creative Corner
2008
Pictures
2010
2005
2006
2009
2007
2003
2011
Off Topic
American Idol
In Loving Memory
Share This
Email to Friend
del.icio.us
Digg it
Facebook
Blogger
Yahoo MyWeb
«Prev
1
2
3
4
5
…
19
20
Next»
Jump
Kelly Clarkson Express
>
American Idol
>
AMERICAN IDOL SEASON 8 "Hollywood Week" - will make new thread when Top 36 starts **SPOILERS INSIDE**
Click to subscribe by RSS
Click to receive E-mail notifications of replies